The Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC) and CLDF brought the problem to Luster's attention after the DEC ignored repeated attempts by CLDF to inform them that the permit may have been issued against federal law. The U.S. Clean Water Act prohibits new SPDES permits for discharges that will cause or contribute to violation of water quality standards set by the Clean Water Act. LSC would reduce water quality by adding heat to the lake and by transferring phosphorus from the bottom of the lake to the surface.
Cayuga Lake has been on a New York State list of impaired waterbodies since 1996 and swimming has been prohibited at Stewart Park for more than 30 years because of poor water quality.
CLDF 1999